Governed or Bullied?

Let's Express Posted on by

Motor tax is a bit of a racket. In theory, we pay it for the maintenance and upgrading of our road system. A recent addition to this is the imposition of a fine factor inside the motor tax because cars are not flipper-friendly. Apparently, the bigger the engines the more carbons emitted and flipper just hates that.

That's the theory of motor tax Irish style. In reality our road tax is being used to prop up Irish Water, as we heard not too long ago and local authorities are using other funds to look after our roads. EU money built the motorways and the Government sold off stretches to tolling companies for a song. That means more money you must pay to drive. 

Now I used to like cars until I realized they were the single biggest drain on my meagre resources. You pay VAT on the purchase of a car, VAT on the (expensive) fuel to run it, VAT on the bills to keep it on the road and tax for using the road as well. Then there are the myriad of fines for not being perfect all of the time. Car Insurance which is compulsory, also has VAT added and most of us need a car just to get to work and pay income tax. So if you were to lose your job all of a sudden, the car becomes a luxurious liability. 

In the past, you just parked it and perhaps even advertised it for sale. You would have reasoned that you aren't using the damn thing, you are emitting no carbons so you owe nothing to anybody. Your motor is off the road with the battery running down and the tyres going flat. For you, your car is a temporary memory until times get better.

I mentioned bad laws in a recent post and one of these was snuck in during August 2013. Now motorists  who forget or fail to declare their car is off the road will be forced to pay arrears and at least three months' motor tax under tough new rules aimed at clamping down on evasion. The Department of the Environment said that anyone planning not to drive their car on a public road must tell their local tax office at least three months in advance. How's that for pure bureaucratic cheek?

You normally do not get much notice of a redundancy and what happens if you accidentally fall down the stairs and are made suddenly unable to drive? Are you supposed to anticipate such events three months in advance? At the time this law was passed, the then Environment Minister Phil Hogan said the system would deal on a local basis with cases where, for example, a person fell ill suddenly and could not use their car but could not declare it was off the road to their local tax office. I suggest that the sick person may not even be able to get out of bed to be 'dealt with locally.' And what does, "The system would deal on a local basis with cases" really mean? Is this the wink and elbow language of delight? Do you give the nod to a Garda you know? No you don't!

The bill clearly states that, "Forms will be submitted directly to motor tax offices or online, instead of at Garda stations." So do you know someone in the Motor Tax Office? This kind of nonsense infuriates me. It is political double-speak where the meat of this new law states firmly that, "The non-use declaration must be made three months in advance." It is obvious then that any "deal on a local basis," must be done by knowing somebody in authority. Otherwise the new (bad) law is black and white and the Gardai are entitled to fine you. Remember, a non-taxed car can be confiscated. 

This is a bad law that doesn't make sense to any normal person and it pre-supposes that all of us are just looking for ways to break the law. I don't like the tone of that but I'm sure you agree though that if politicians make bad laws, (for their own reasons), then ordinary decent honest people might just react by thinking, to hell with that. Look at the water tax as an example of it! This opens a further debate which should prompt you to consider some more. Do we obey our laws voluntarily because we believe it is for the common good or do we begrudgingly obey them because of the consequences of not doing so? Are we being governed or bullied?

 

Us & Them

Let's Express Posted on by

A very old friend told me a touching story in the pub last Friday and it was one that made me think about things as they have become today.

Back in the early seventies he knew of a big Garda Sergeant who hailed from the West of Ireland but plodded the beat in a Leinster town. A well-known wag in the town drove as a commercial traveler by day and drank his head off at night in the local boozer. The Sergeant had seen him many times make his way unsteadily to his car for the short drive home. Then one night, he'd had way too much and the copper pulled him over.

One look at the guy and he asked him to get out and get into the passenger seat. The Sergeant them drove them both to the man's house and handed him over to his wife. But he took the time to tell the wife about the repeated drink-driving and said that if it happened again, he'd have to put the guy off the road and he'd lose his job as a result. This massive Sergeant turned his doe-eyes to the wife and pleaded with her to sort her husband out.

It was very intelligent policing because our commercial traveller kept his job and marriage as a result. The rural Sergeant knew that a police warning would make little difference but setting the wife on the guy changed everything. As such, it is one of the best examples of 'crime prevention' I had ever heard. The policeman and the civilian stayed friends too and the rural Leinster town had little crime at that time. Further, what crime there was got solved because that Sergeant could rely on the locals to tell him everything. You see, they liked and trusted him, simple as that.

Fast forward to today's Ireland and that has all changed. The Gardai are a pretty impersonal lot now and their capacity for making a value-judgement on the spot is all but gone. Today, the above offender would automatically be off the road and out of a job and his wife would have left him. Perhaps then rather than teaching him a lesson the whole affair could tip him over the edge. Maybe instead of giving up the drink he might turn to it in his desperation. And what does that achieve?

We have a good police force in Ireland but they cannot do their job without our help. Just like we depend on the Gardai, they depend on us. The expression, "Gardai are asking for witnesses," is regularly heard and when serious crimes go to court they need us on those juries as well. They even have their own P.R. Department to liaise with the public. The fact that our uniformed Gardai are unarmed makes us appreciate them and their bravery even more in today's society. There is respect for the force in the general population but I sense that the politicians are diminishing our respect for our protectors.

They closed their community Garda stations by the dozen and allowed, (even incentivised) senior members to retire in droves. Then they hit them in the pocket too. They send them out in cheap cars with bad equipment to fight well-heeled violent drug dealers and they even made a hash of the communications system 'Pulse' forcing individual Gardai to use their own mobile phones. But worst of all to my mind, they have introduced a raft of petty small-minded laws to harass the citizen at every twist and turn and then left it to the Gardai to infuriate us. The penalty points system is a case in point. GATSO vans make a fortune catching us doing a couple of miles over the limit and before we know where we are, we are in the frame to be put off the road. This threatens our job prospects and makes us very resentful and guess who we take out the resentment on? The Garda uniform is the symbol of that repression and many quietly vow not to be so helpful to them again should they need it.

Bad laws will always bring bad outcomes. Politicians eager to make an impression as a 'tough nut' can send the force out to break up legal protests with force. When that happens, it becomes a case of us and them – the people versus the Gardai. Take the NCT for example. They are running long waiting lists so if your test is due this month and you phone them to book it now, you won't get an appointment for ages, through no fault of your own. However, it means that your car technically has not been passed to be on the road. That's bad enough but did you know that the Gardai can then order you out of your car and leave it at the roadside until you organize to have it transported, at a huge unexpected cost. Depending on where you are ordered to leave the car it could also be vandalized overnight. And the infuriating thing is that the car itself was perfectly roadworthy before you were stopped. But the politicians made it an offense under law and the attending Garda could fine you as well and because the offense is covered by the Road Traffic Act you could be subject to penalty points. For what? 

The more I talk to decent ordinary guys about this the more I see a hunted look cross their faces. What saddens me is that their anger and annoyance is not directed at the politicians for the stupid laws but it's aimed squarely at the poor Garda who had to enforce those laws. They feel cheated and wronged and I would suggest that they would be less inclined to be model citizens who might come forward with information to help the Gardai with their inquiries in the future. 

Years ago we used to talk about the fabric of society. Central to that civic idea was always the relationship between the civil population and the force. There was give and take on both sides and that relationship was warm and good-natured in the main. We all were outraged if one of them was shot while on duty and we took it as a personal affront to our core decency. That decency is now being tested to the limit and it is not an exaggeration to suggest that a wedge is being driven between the guardians and the guarded to further the careers of selfish short-sighted politicians and vested interests. 

Unless it is rolled back and a new Government strikes out many of the stupid laws that have been passed, things could become very uneasy and neither the Gardai nor the people will be to blame for that.

Elaborate Hoax

Let's Express Posted on by


I will never understand why the private gambling debts of the banks had to be socialised. When there were profits they were private but when stupidity by the private banks began returning losses, these losses became all of our responsibility. Regardless of the soft-soaping by politicians, this was immoral and wrong and for the religious among you, it was also sinful.

But short of a violent revolution, (????), it has taken root and the financial problem, not of your making or mine, now has to be repaid by us we are told. Now here is the second thing I don't understand. Every economist and political commentator agrees that the debt is just to large to be repaid. There is common agreement that whoever we owe it all to, is never going to get their money. The reason for this is that the economy is knackered. With a knackered economy we are not generating the surpluses to pay anyone we are indebted to.

That leads me to the third thing I don't understand. To get a knackered economy going again we need investment. Investment stimulates growth with resultant jobs and profits and this gets the  economy going again. But instead of investment we opted for austerity and job losses so the economy shrank. We in fact, reduced our ability to pay anything.

So then they really baffled me. We borrowed so much money to give to the banks that our debt interest alone each year is eight billion euros and we're struggling to even meet that without ever addressing the capital sums. You see, what really perplexes me is the idea of borrowing your way out of impossible debts. I just don't get it. None of us right now knows whether Baldy Noonan is borrowing billions to meet the billions in interest we are supposed to be paying back on previous money. 

But then I read an interesting fact about the euro, (and all currencies). The value of a euro is one euro only because all of us BELIEVE it is. If we ceased to believe it the euro would be worthless. By extension then, if we ceased to believe we really owed a 'squillion' euros to some foreign Johnies then this un-payable debt would simply disappear. 

That is what I am beginning to understand because in amongst the deceit and lies of the last seven years one thing has become very clear. Money, as in currency, is worthless and its only value is to scare and enslave us to those with true wealth. That is what all the bullshit is about!

In the Loop

Let's Express Posted on by

I am grateful to my friend and mentor "Grandad" for the following incomplete list of the taxes we are all subject to in Ireland.

  • Airline surcharge tax
  • Airline Fuel Tax
  • Airport Maintenance Tax
  • Broadcasting Charge [tax]
  • Building Permit Tax
  • Capital Gains Tax
  • Corporate Income Tax
  • Death Duty Tax
  • Dog Licence [tax]
  • Domestic Oil Tax
  • Driving Licence Tax
  • Environmental Tax
  • Fishing License Tax
  • Food License Tax
  • Goods and Services Tax
  • Health Tax
  • Income Tax
  • Inheritance Tax
  • Interest Tax
  • Liquor Tax
  • Luxury Taxes
  • Marriage License Tax
  • National Car Test 
  • Personal Income Tax
  • Petrol Tax
  • Property Tax
  • Prescription Drug Tax
  • Recreational Vehicle Tax
  • Retail Sales Tax
  • Road Fund Licence [tax]
  • Service Charge Tax
  • Septic Tank Tax
  • Stamp Duty [tax]
  • Telephone Tax
  • Tobacco Excise Duty [tax]
  • Value Added Tax
  • Vehicle License Registration Tax
  • Vehicle Sales Tax
  • Water Tax
  • Workers Compensation Tax

Growing up here in the seventies and eighties it was a lot simpler. Central taxation was underwriting local Government and as a result, we paid for our water, street lighting, domestic waste disposal, street cleaning and roads among other things via income tax and VAT. Car tax came in after that and it was the first indication that senior Civil Servants were looking for ways to rip us off. Cue property and water taxes! We even pay our bin charges to private companies now. Traditionally when we bought our homes we paid all of the property tax up front in a lump sum called Stamp Duty. You paid for water in the subvention grants to local authorities who supplied it.

This begs the question, what do we pay our politicians and public representatives for? What is it that all those hundreds of civil servants do for us at such a high cost? The answer is truly amazing. Politicians repeatedly claim that do NOT create jobs nor are they supposed to. The 166 of them who collect in Dail Eireann from time to time maintain that they are elected to "MAKE LAWS." You didn't know that, did you? For a hundred grand a year plus the same again in expenses, these joker's sole purpose in life is to make more new laws. And if you look at the laws this current Government have made since entering office you will discover that most of them have to do with raiding your wallet ………. LEGALLY! Oh, and the Civil Servants do what the politicians tell them to do and nothing else.

It has become an infinite loop in fact. They introduce laws to give them more of your money so that they can bribe you to vote for them at election time and the three main parties have been doing just that for years. Even worse, they want you to understand that it is a public service to us. How's that for pure brazenness? 

You couldn't make it up.